•  

Flashing Bill Cosby

November 3rd, 2011 by Brandon Stanton | 15 Comments »

I first met Holly last week on 5th Avenue.  I was walking down the sidewalk when I looked up and saw a pair of tits.  My mind wasn’t ready for it.  There are never tits on 5th Avenue.  I felt like a Native American first seeing the ships of Columbus.   What are these things doing here?   But like a true professional, I pushed through my shock and immediately asked Holly for her portrait.

The following day, I posted the photo to the HONY Facebook Group.  Holly’s tits got a big response.  Nearly 50 people commented on the photo.   Most were supportive of Holly: she was brave, a trailblazer, an activist.  Somebody recognized Holly and tagged her in the picture.  Later that evening she ended up joining the discussion.  Everything was very scholarly and liberating until Facebook removed the photo.  No woman tits, said Facebook.  Only man tits.   I was morally outraged.  This seemed to be the worst sort of discrimination.  Facebook was sending a horrible message to the young women of America:  even though your tits are equal, they must be kept separate.  That sort of injustice could not stand.  It was time for a Rosa Parks of tits.  I messaged Holly and asked for an interview.

————————————————————————————————-

Holly and I agreed to meet yesterday at the Barnes and Nobles on 5th Avenue.  You can come see what I do, she told me.  I had no idea what she meant by that.  I expected to find her bare-chested, defiant, and forcing pamphlets into the clenched hands of tourists.  But when I arrived she was fully clothed.  She was rocking on her heels.  She looked nervous as shit.
“I’m nervous as shit,” she said.
“Why?  What’s going on?”
“Bill Cosby’s in there. “  Holly pointed at the bookstore. “He’s signing books.  When he comes out, I’m going to flash him.  That’s what I do.”
That’s what you do?”
“Yeah, me and my friends are artists.  I’m trying to get attention so I try to flash celebrities.  I take off my shirt and run up to them.  You know, like a topless paparazzo.  That’s what I call myself—Holly Van Voast, Topless Paparazzo.”

So maybe Holly wasn’t Rosa Parks after all.  But she did symbolize something important.  Something much more relevant to our modern world: “It’s not enough to be talented anymore,” she explained.  “You’ve got to be able to get people’s attention.”

We hadn’t been talking for long when a silver Cadillac pulled up to the curb, and a sweater-clad Bill Cosby stepped out onto the sidewalk.  He waved to a few people on the street and then disappeared inside the store.   “Holy shit!” I said, losing composure.  “There he goes!  We missed him.  He just went inside– let’s follow him.”
“We can’t.” said Holly.  “They won’t let me inside.”
“Why’s that?”  I asked.
“I flashed Snooki a couple weeks ago.  They know what I look like.”

———————————————————————————————————–

Since we had some time before Cosby re-emerged, I suggested to Holly that we go to Rockefeller Center and take some portraits.  Holly seemed hesitant to leave her post, but eventually agreed.  “Let’s make it quick,” she said.  “We’ve got to be here when he comes back.”

We didn’t last long at Rockefeller Center before security kicked us out.  But I managed to get some great portraits.




——————————————————————————————————————————————————————
 
When we got back to the Barnes and Noble, the silver Cadillac was parked outside of the front entrance.  The line for autographs was growing smaller, and it was clear that our target would be emerging shortly.  Holly assumed position behind a newspaper dispenser.   She looked around nervously.  She fidgeted with a thread hanging from her sweater.

I noticed that the driver of the Cadillac was eying us suspiciously in the rearview mirror, so I pretended to read a newspaper while I spoke to Holly out of the side of my mouth: “You stay out of sight,” I said.  “I’ll get into position for a better view.  When I raise my camera to my face, you’ll know he’s coming.”  I split off and positioned myself between the Cadillac and the front entrance.  Then I waited.

Within minutes I was joined by a handful of middle-aged men with cameras around their necks.  These were members of the paparazzi.  They seemed to share a strange, sad camaraderie.  They exchanged horribly depressing pieces of inside information:  I hear Kris Jenner is going to a gallery opening tonight, one of them whispered.   She’ll probably hit the 54th Street Starbucks afterward.   One man came up to me and spoke in a very low voice: I hear that the 16 Handles Yogurt Shop is a great place to relax, he said.  I thought for sure he was retarded, so I just smiled politely.  Then he continued:  You know, it’s a great place to relax your hand.  When you’re finished signing autographs.  Man these people were depressing.  I wasn’t here to photograph Bill Cosby.  I was here to make sure he saw Holly’s tits.

I waited for what seemed like an hour.  I started to get very cold.  No Cosby.  I could see that Holly was getting restless.  He should have finished by now.  Things weren’t looking good.  Then disaster struck: the silver Cadillac started up and pulled away from the curb.  A decoy!  Damn you Cosby!  I walked over to Holly: “What do you think?”  I asked.  “Did they smuggle him out the back?”

“I bet they are going to take him out the emergency exit,” she said.  “Just like they did with Snooki.  Follow me.”  Holly led me to a door on the other side of the building.  Still no sign of the Cadillac.  “All we can do is wait,” she said.  But things weren’t looking good.  It was looking like Cosby may have escaped without seeing Holly’s tits.  But then salvation.  The Cadillac reappeared.  Like the sun.  And we were warmed with renewed hope.  It pulled up to the curb, right in front of the side entrance.  “Stay out of sight,” I told her.  The place was swarming with Barnes and Noble employees now.  “It’s about to go down.”  I gripped my camera tightly.  I checked my settings.  I couldn’t afford any misfires.

Then the door opened.
The target emerged.
Holly ripped off her shirt and leapt into action.




Share this story on Facebook:
Like Humans of New York on Facebook:
  • http://twitter.com/the_chrissie Chrissie Adams

    Ahhhh, now Bill Cosby’s face takes on a new meaning.  He’s giving you that “You set me up, you sonofabitch.” face.  Priceless.

  • Jason

    LOVE IT!

  • Sue_kohn6

    Ya know, I’m guessing if Bill was younger he’d have gotten a kick out of the situation.   Holly is a brave woman – few people push past their fear to get to what they want.  Kudos to her and to you for supporting her.

  • Staci

    This is fantastic! 

  • http://Imyourfanclub.wordpress.com Maia

    Interesting. But kinda sad that she says she’s doing this to get attention for her art. I wish it were enough to be talented. Especially if that talent is flashing Bill Cosby (your boobs)!

  • http://profiles.google.com/tvobob Bob B

    How many Jello pudding pops can she hold up under each breast?

  • Angel Ortega

    I love her! and I love you for helping her too!

  • Maia

    Your proudest moment is a shot of an elderly comedian that obviously did not consent?  The tits is an acknowledged ply for attention, but you seemed to really get caught up in her game.  Maintain perspective, bud.

  • http://twitter.com/Exaggeratedcool Jes Cervoni

    It is kind of weird how the female breasts are the ones that are deemed inappropriate. Sacks of fat on your chest. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/johnevanscs John Evans

    This is all completely bizarre. For one thing, I seem to recall that it’s legal for women to be topless in New York, as long as it’s not for purposes of advertisement. (Does an artistic statement count? Hmmmm…) The other thing that bewilders me is Bill Cosby’s posse going “OMG TITS”. I’m just imagining some bodyguard on a walkie-talkie…”*pssh* COME IN BROWN BEAR – THE PUDDING IS OUT OF THE PACKAGE – KEEP IT AWAY FROM THE TITS, REPEAT, KEEP THE PUDDING AWAY FROM THE TITS”

  • http://backlynx.net/?p=784 Topless Paparazzo Flashes Bill Cosby | Backlynx

    [...] natural-y. M.s Van Toast was “discovered”* by photographer/writer Brandon Stanton when he took some photos of her standing on fifth avenue. She had a camera around her neck and nothing else till you get to the pants. When the Humans of [...]

  • Anna

    I’ve met this woman a few times- First saw her at Occupy Wall Street, just sort of hanging out. Talking to people. Then I saw her at the Saturday-event of Comic Con, outside, explaining herself to some photographers and explaining her game. I’ve seen her definitely at a few places more, but I just thought she was a different person every time and didn’t quite catch where I was.

    As far as the story goes, I liked the tits-are-separate-but-equal concept you addressed here. I’m not sure how I feel about seeing topless women for whatever reason in the streets, but somehow topless men are fine. Why is this? What is this weird social stigma of seeing a chick’s tits outside of a porno or the bedroom? Half the time they’re fake anyway, so who cares?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Nathan-Hicks/15502377 Nathan Hicks

    On the contrary I think that HoNY’s appeal is getting caught up in each person’s game. “Oh! Who are you? You are interesting! Let me walk five steps in your shoes.”

    To say this is Brandon’s proudest moment is laughable.

  • http://www.newyorkwritesitself.com/2011/11/2783/ Humans of New York | New York Writes Itself

    [...] which he shot the marathoners who crossed the finish line long after the crowds have left, and Flashing Bill Cosby, in which – well, you know. You’ll have to check that one out on his [...]

  • Hammontonphotography

    This is great.  I found this story after reading through the Bill Clinton experience.  Way to go and awesome story about meeting  her, supporting her, etc.  That’s awesome.. and even though most people might not understand why she is doing what she does – I do (it’s her form of art) and that is her statement.  I am a photographer as well (and love your work btw), and I have respect for all types of art, may it be music, writing, painting, photography etc..  It’s one’s creation and it’s them.. and her idea is not only unique but it is also very interesting.  Great shots of the Cosby moment, and I love the last one.. his expression after the ‘moment’ is priceless. 

Wall Street World Trade Center Chinatown SoHo Washington Square Union Square Grand Central Station Times Square The Metropolitan Museum Lincoln Center Museum of Natural History Central Park Financial District Lower East Side City Hall TriBeCa East Village / Lower East Side Middle Village West Village Murray Hill / Gramercy Flatiron / Lower Midtown Chelsea East Midtown Midtown Hells Kitchen Upper East Side (Lower) Upper West Side (Lower) Upper East Side (Upper) Upper West Side (Upper) El Barrio / East Harlem Harlem (Lower) Columbia / Morningside Heights Harlem (Upper) Manhattanville / Hamilton Heights Washington Heights Fort George / Fort Tryon Inwood